Key Takeaways
- New Mexico ranks #1 for states where patients should be most cautious, due to low hospital quality and the lowest private insurance rate.
- Three southern states, Mississippi, Kentucky, and Louisiana, appear in the top 10, suggesting a regional pattern of healthcare risk.
- Medical mistakes are now the third leading cause of death in the U.S., reinforcing the importance of choosing providers carefully.
Medical errors are now the third leading cause of death in the United States, claiming over 250,000 lives each year. In this landscape, patients and their families must be more vigilant than ever when selecting a healthcare provider. But these concerns go beyond hospitals; they extend into long-term care facilities, where vulnerable seniors often face some of the most serious risks.
To help identify where patients need to exercise the most caution, Your Insurance Attorney analyzed healthcare risk across all 50 states.
We reviewed critical indicators like:
- Malpractice report frequency
- Average compensation per claim
- Number of practicing physicians per capita
- Deaths due to medical complications
- Private insurance coverage rates
- Hospital quality scores
By using public data from:
Each metric was adjusted for population and combined into a composite score. Higher scores indicate greater overall healthcare risk, signaling where individuals should be particularly selective and informed when seeking care.
Top 10 States Where Patients Should Be Most Attentive
1. New Mexico – Score: 99
New Mexico leads the list with the lowest private insurance coverage in the U.S. (54.4%), a low hospital quality score (69.15), and a limited number of physicians. These systemic issues elevate both access and outcome risks.
2. Louisiana – Score: 98
With the highest malpractice report rate (34.6 per 100K residents) and one of the highest complication-related death rates, Louisiana’s healthcare environment presents significant risks that demand patient awareness.
3. Mississippi – Score: 97
Mississippi combines high complication death rates (14.95), low average payouts ($28.3K), and the fewest physicians per capita, reflecting poor outcomes and limited access to care.
4. Vermont – Score: 96
Despite strong physician availability, Vermont has one of the highest complication-related death rates (20.05) and the second-lowest average payout per malpractice case, raising concerns about both patient safety and accountability.
5. Nevada – Score: 90
Nevada’s low physician availability and poor hospital quality rating contribute to a risk-heavy environment for patients.
6. Arizona – Score: 80
Arizona shares many of Nevada’s challenges, with low hospital quality (68.05) and physician scarcity, contributing to an elevated healthcare risk score.
7. Kentucky – Score: 78
Kentucky ranks seventh due to a high complication death rate (11.02) and limited private insurance coverage (62.8%), which often correlate with uneven care quality.
8. Arkansas – Score: 77
Arkansas suffers from both access issues (only 21.7 physicians per 10K residents) and poor compensation for malpractice victims ($42.76K average payout), underscoring the need for patient vigilance.
9. Wyoming – Score: 76
Wyoming has the second-highest malpractice report rate and the lowest average payout at just $10.46K. It also has the highest complication death rate in the country, reflecting serious care deficiencies.
10. Florida – Score: 74
Florida’s hospital quality score is the worst in the U.S. (66.85), and it also ranks high for complication-related deaths. Even with a reasonable number of physicians, patients must navigate serious quality-of-care issues.
Here is the summary of the findings:
| State | Malpractice Reports per 100K residents | Malpractice Payout per Report (Thousands USD) | Physicians per 10K residents | Deaths from Medical Complications per 1M residents | Percentage of population with private health insurance | Hospital Quality Score | Final score |
| New Mexico | 17.81 | 211.23 | 24.20 | 12.15 | 54.4 | 69.15 | 99 |
| Louisiana | 34.55 | 39.35 | 28.20 | 11.29 | 58.1 | 76.95 | 98 |
| Mississippi | 19.78 | 28.32 | 19.80 | 14.95 | 61.5 | 73.95 | 97 |
| Vermont | 22.21 | 19.86 | 39.00 | 20.05 | 70.0 | 72.40 | 96 |
| Nevada | 18.46 | 70.90 | 20.60 | 8.13 | 63.4 | 68.15 | 90 |
| Arizona | 16.81 | 58.94 | 24.90 | 7.54 | 63.9 | 68.05 | 80 |
| Kentucky | 20.56 | 86.28 | 24.40 | 11.02 | 62.8 | 72.55 | 78 |
| Arkansas | 18.18 | 42.76 | 21.70 | 10.94 | 60.0 | 74.25 | 77 |
| Wyoming | 25.76 | 10.46 | 63.00 | 22.03 | 71.0 | 74.40 | 76 |
| Florida | 14.00 | 112.64 | 27.00 | 7.84 | 63.6 | 66.85 | 74 |
*You can find the full research findings here.
Why This Matters for Families of Nursing Home Residents
These healthcare risk patterns do not stop at hospitals. Long-term care facilities, including nursing homes, assisted living facilities, and group homes, often reflect the same systemic issues seen in this report, including low provider oversight, poor outcomes, and inadequate compensation when things go wrong.
That is why Your Insurance Attorney now has a dedicated team of experienced nursing home abuse lawyers helping families protect their loved ones. Since the 1990s, our attorneys have successfully litigated cases against every major nursing home chain operating in Florida. We have represented families in trials, arbitrations, and even testified before the Florida Legislature and the U.S. Congress to strengthen protections for seniors.
If your loved one has been neglected, injured, or abused in a nursing home, assisted living facility, or group home, we are here to help. Our nationally recognized legal team has spent four decades on the front lines of nursing home abuse litigation, and we are committed to holding these facilities accountable.
Take Action Today
Healthcare risks are real, and they extend into the places we trust to care for our most vulnerable. If you suspect a loved one has suffered neglect or abuse in a nursing facility, contact Your Insurance Attorney today. Let our experienced nursing home lawyers review your case and fight to protect your family’s rights.
